|
Pollutant |
Factor |
Sensitivity |
Comment |
|
C2H4 pollution |
Tissue age |
Epinasty in immature leaves. Other symptoms on oldest leaves first. |
Tissues with high natural C2H4 are more sensitive. |
|
C2H4 pollution |
High temperature |
Sensitivity increased |
|
|
C2H4 pollution |
Other pollutants |
Effects inhibited by high levels of SO2 or CO2 |
|
|
Cl2 pollution |
Bright sunshine |
Sensitivity increased |
|
|
Cl2 pollution |
Tissue age |
Little effect; in conifers, current year’s needles most sensitive |
Immature leaves tolerant in some species. |
|
Cl2 pollution |
Wet leaves |
No effect |
|
|
Cl2 pollution |
Drought |
Sensitivity decreased |
|
|
Cl2 pollution |
Low temperature |
Sensitivity decreased in pines |
Symptoms take longer to develop. |
|
Cl2 pollution |
Plat age |
Seedling less sensitive than oleder plants |
|
|
HCl pollution |
Tissue age |
Young, fully expanded leaves most sensitive |
Immature leaves tolerant. |
|
HCl pollution |
Plant age |
Seedlings less sensitive than mature plants |
Older plants become more tolerant. |
|
HCl pollution |
High relat. Humidity |
Sensitivity increased |
|
|
HCl pollution |
Ca-deficit |
Sensitivity decreased |
Effect shown for Nasturtium. May be different for other species. |
|
HCl pollution |
Ca-excess |
Sensitivity increased |
Effect shown for Nasturtium. May be different for other species. |
|
HCl pollution |
Cl-deficit |
Sensitivity increased |
Effect shown for Nasturtium. May be different for other species. |
|
HCl pollution |
Cl-excess |
Sensitivity increased |
Effect shown for Nasturtium. May be different for other species. |
|
HCl pollution |
Mg-deficit |
Sensitivity increased |
|
|
NH3 pollution |
Concentration |
Variable |
Some conifers sensitive at moderate but tolerant at high levels. |
|
NH3 pollution |
Tissue age |
Little effect |
|
|
NH3 pollution |
Darkness |
Variable |
|
|
NH3 pollution |
Drought |
Sensitivity decreased |
|
|
NH3 pollution |
Wet leaves |
Sensitivity increased |
Symptoms develop faster. |
|
NOx pollution |
Ca-excess |
Sensitivity decreased |
Opposite effect in some species. |
|
NOx pollution |
Tissue age |
Immature leaves/needles most sensitive |
|
|
NOx pollution |
Cultivar |
Highly variable; especially in gladiolus & tomato |
In gladiolus, sensitivity related to flower colour |
|
NOx pollution |
High relat. humidity |
Sensitivity increased |
|
|
NOx pollution |
Low temperature |
Sensitivity decreased; symptom expression delayed |
|
|
NOx pollution |
Drought |
Sensitivity decreased; symptoms induced in conifers needles previously exposed. |
Sensitivity increased in some fruit trees. |
|
NOx pollution |
N-deficit |
Sensitivity decreased |
Opposite effect in some species. |
|
NOx pollution |
Ca-deficit |
Sensitivity decreased |
Opposite effect in some species. |
|
NOx pollution |
N-excess |
Sensitivity decreased |
Opposite effect in some species. |
|
NOx pollution |
P-excess |
Sensitivity increased |
Opposite effect in some species. |
|
NOx pollution |
Other pollutants |
Interaction with SO2, NO2, O2 & hydrocarbons |
Response varies with concentrations and relative proportions. |
|
NOx pollution |
K-deficit |
Sensitivity increased |
Opposite effect in some species. |
|
O3 pollution |
K-excess |
Variable sensitivity |
|
|
O3 pollution |
N-excess |
Variable sensitivity |
|
|
O3 pollution |
Plant age |
Young plants most sensitive |
|
|
O3 pollution |
Tissue age |
Intermediate leaves usually most sensitive |
|
|
O3 pollution |
Darkness |
Sensitivity decreased |
Plants grown in low light are more sensitive. High light during exposure increases injury. |
|
O3 pollution |
Wet leaves |
Variable sensitivity |
|
|
O3 pollution |
Drought |
Sensitivity decreased |
|
|
O3 pollution |
Other pollutants |
Interactions with SO2, NO2, PAN & heavy metals |
Response varies with species, concentration & relative proportions |
|
O3 pollution |
High soil salinity |
Sensitivity decreased |
|
|
O3 pollution |
High relat. Humidity |
Sensitivity increased |
|
|
O3 pollution |
S-excess |
Sensitivity decreased |
|
|
O3 pollution |
N-deficit |
Variable sensitivity |
|
|
O3 pollution |
P-deficit |
Sensitivity decreased |
|
|
O3 pollution |
Low temperature |
Sensitivity decreased |
Sensitivity decreases again above 30 degree C. Response varies according to dose. |
|
O3 pollution |
K-deficit |
Variable sensitivity |
|
|
PAN pollution |
High relat. Humidity |
No effect |
|
|
PAN pollution |
Tissue age |
Young, rapidly expanding leaves most sensitive |
Sensitivity strongly affected by physiological age, results in bands of damage. |
|
PAN pollution |
Other pollutants |
Interactions with O3 & SO2 |
Response varies with concentrations & pollutant. |
|
PAN pollution |
Drought |
Sensitivity decreased |
|
|
PAN pollution |
Time of day |
Sensitivity more in morning than after noon |
|
|
PAN pollution |
Darkness |
Injury eliminated. Sensitivity increases with increased light intensity |
Presence of light before, during and after exposure must for injury to occur. |
|
PAN pollution |
Low temperature |
Injury decreased |
|
|
PAN pollution |
Plant age |
Young plants more sensitive |
|
|
SO2 pollution |
Other pollutant |
Interaction with O3, NO2, HF |
Response varies with concentrations and relative proportions. |
|
SO2 pollution |
Time of day |
More sensitivity when sugar content low |
In many plants in the morning. |
|
SO2 pollution |
High relat. Humidity |
Sensitivity increased |
|
|
SO2 pollution |
Drought |
Sensitivity decreased |
|
|
SO2 pollution |
High wind |
Sensitivity increased |
|
|
SO2 pollution |
Wet leaves |
Variable; may increase |
|
|
SO2 pollution |
Darkness |
Sensitivity decreased |
Some plants e.g. Potato not closing stomata at night may be unaffected. |
|
SO2 pollution |
Low temperature |
Sensitivity decreased |
Susceptibility to frost injury increased by SO2 exposure |
|
SO2 pollution |
Plant age |
Seedlings more sensitive than older plants |
|
|
SO2 pollution |
Season |
Grasses more sensitive in winter; conifers more in April/May than in July/August |
Not vry important for very short exposures. |
|
SO2 pollution |
N-deficit |
Sensitivity decreased |
|
|
SO2 pollution |
S-deficit |
Sensitivity decreased |
|
|
SO2 pollution |
P-deficit |
Sensitivity decreased |
|
|
SO2 pollution |
N-excess |
Sensitivity decreased |
|
|
SO2 pollution |
K-deficit |
Sensitivity increased |
|
|
SO2 pollution |
S-excess |
Sensitivity increased |
|
|
SO2 pollution |
Tissue age |
Most in young, fully expanded leaves |
|
|
SO2 pollution |
Ca-deficit |
Sensitivity increased |
|
August 12, 2008
FACTORS AFFECTING PLANT SENSTIVITY TO AIR POLLUTANTS
HABITAT AND PLANT RESPONSE
|
Cause |
Common name |
Botanical name |
Plant part |
Symptom |
|
Cold area |
Pea |
Pisum sativum |
Leaf |
Bronzing |
|
Cold area |
Bean |
Phaseolus vulgaris |
Leaf |
Bronzing |
|
Cold area |
Spinach |
Spinacea oleracea |
Leaf |
Bronzing |
|
Dry area |
Pine |
Pinus sp. |
Needle |
Tip burn; sharp boundaary between necrotic and healthy tissue |
|
Dry area |
Spruce |
Picea sp. |
Needle |
Tip burn; sharp boundaary between necrotic and healthy tissue |
|
Dry area |
Fir |
Abies sp. |
Needle |
Tip burn; sharp boundaary between necrotic and healthy tissue |
|
Dry area |
Aspen |
Populus tremula |
Leaf |
Tip necrosis with sharp boundary |
|
Dry area |
Plum |
Prunus domestica |
Leaf |
Marginal/interveinal necrosis, boundary chlorotic & diffuse |
|
Dry area |
Wych elm |
Ulmus glabra |
Leaf |
Tip necrosis with sharp boundary |
|
Dry area |
Willow |
Salix sp. |
Leaf |
Tip necrosis with sharp boundary |
|
Dry area |
Cherry |
Prunus avium |
Leaf |
Marginal/interveinal necrosis, boundary chlorotic & diffuse |
|
Dry area |
Oak |
Quercus rubur (Q. pedunculata) |
Leaf |
Interveinal brown/bronzed lesions |
|
Dry area |
Apple |
Malus sylvestris |
Fruit |
Dark lesions |
|
Dry area |
Cherry |
Prunus avium |
Fruit |
Brown/black depression at tip |
|
Dry area |
Pear |
Pyrus communis |
Fruit |
Brown/black depression at tip |
|
Dry area |
Tomato |
Lycopersicum esculentum |
Fruit |
Blossom end rot |
|
Water logged area |
Lucerne (alfalfa) |
Medicago sativa |
Leaf |
White stipple |
|
Hot area |
Onion |
Allium cepa |
Leaf |
Tip necrosis; white/grey stipple |
|
Hot area |
Horse chestnut |
Aesculus hippocastanum |
Leaf |
Marginal necrosis |
|
Hot area |
Lettuce |
Lectuca sativa |
Leaf |
Brown stipple of veins |
|
Hot area |
Lucerne (alfalfa) |
Medicago sativa |
Leaf |
White stipple |
|
Cold area |
Lucerne (alfalfa) |
Medicago sativa |
Leaf |
Necrotic stipple |
|
Cold area |
Potato |
Solanum tuberosum |
Leaf |
Black discolouration; necrotic stipple |
NUTRIENT DEFICIENCY SYMPTOMS IN PLANTS
Cause |
Common name |
Botanical name |
Plant part |
Symptom |
|
K-deficit |
Pear |
Pyrus communis |
Leaf |
Upward curling |
|
K-deficit |
Pea |
Pisum sativum |
Leaf |
Brown stipple |
|
K-deficit |
Potato |
Solanum tuberosum |
Leaf |
Bronzing of lower surface; marginal, later interveinal necrosis |
|
K-deficit |
Tomato |
Lycopersicum esculentum |
Leaf |
Marginal, later interveinal necrosis |
|
K-deficit |
Lucerne (alfalfa) |
Medicago sativa |
Leaf |
Marginal, later interveinal necrosis |
|
P-deficit |
Cabbage |
Brassica oleracea var. capitata |
Leaf |
Red/purple discolouration |
|
P-deficit |
Lucerne (alfalfa) |
Medicago sativa |
Leaf |
Red/purple discolouration |
|
P-deficit |
Potato |
Solanum tuberosum |
Leaf |
Curling or rolling |
|
S-deficit |
Tomato |
Lycopersicum esculentum |
Leaf |
Very pale new leaf; Bleached old leaf |
|
Ca-deficit |
Tulip |
Tulipa gesneriana |
Leaf |
Necrosis |
|
Ca-deficit |
Tulip |
Tulipa gesneriana |
Plant |
Wilting |
|
Mg-deficit |
Pear |
Pyrus communis |
Leaf |
Black necrosis |
|
Mg-deficit |
Potato |
Solanum tuberosum |
Leaf |
Brown stipple |
|
Mg-deficit |
Tomato |
Lycopersicum esculentum |
Leaf |
Curling & brittleness |
|
Mn-deficit |
Oats |
Avena sativa |
Leaf |
Grey discolouration |
|
Mn-deficit |
Wheat |
Triticum vulgare |
Leaf |
White dashes |
|
Mn-deficit |
Wheat |
Triticum vulgare |
Plant |
Pale floppy appearance |
|
Mn-deficit |
Barley |
Hordeum vulgare |
Plant |
Pale floppy appearance |
|
Mn-deficit |
Barley |
Hordeum vulgare |
Leaf |
White dashes |
|
Zn-deficit |
Lucerne (alfalfa) |
Medicago sativa |
Leaf |
White stipple on lower & Bronzing of upper surface |
|
Zn-deficit |
Tomato |
Lycopersicum esculentum |
Leaf |
Interveinal chlorosis, later necrosis |
|
Mn-excess |
Cauliflower |
Brassica oleracea var. botrytis |
Leaf |
Brown/purple stipple |
|
Mn-excess |
Potato |
Solanum tuberosum |
Leaf/stem |
Black stipple or streaks |
MINIMUM EXPOSURE TO AIR POLLUTANTS FOR PLANT INJURY
| Plant name | Pollutant |
ppm | hours | tolerance |
| Alder | HCl | 6.00 | 4.00 | Middle |
| Aster | HCl | 9.00 | 0.40 | Low |
| Barley | HCl | 7.00 | 0.40 | Very low |
| Bean | HCl | 4.00 | 0.40 | Very low |
| Beech | HCl | 1000.00 | 1.00 | Very high |
| Cherry | HCl | 9.00 | 4.00 | High |
| Chrysanthemum | HCl | 9.00 | 3.00 | High |
| Cornflower | HCl | 20.00 | 0.40 | Middle |
| Cosmos | HCl | 9.00 | 0.40 | Low |
| Douglas fir | HCl | 10.00 | 4.00 | High |
| Marigold | HCl | 9.00 | 0.40 | Low |
| Nasturtium | HCl | 9.00 | 0.40 | Low |
| Norway maple | HCl | 7.00 | 4.00 | High |
| Norway spruce | HCl | 19.00 | 4.00 | Very high |
| Oak | HCl | 1000.00 | 1.00 | Very high |
| Tomato | HCl | 5.00 | 2.00 | Low |
| Tulip tree | HCl | 3.00 | 4.00 | Low |
| Weymouth pine | HCl | 8.00 | 4.00 | High |
| Zinnia | HCl | 9.00 | 0.40 | Low |
| Annual poa | NH3 | 12.00 | 4.00 | Middle |
| Buckwheat | NH3 | 16.60 | 4.00 | Middle |
| Chickweed | NH3 | 12.00 | 4.00 | Middle |
| Dandelion | NH3 | 12.00 | 4.00 | Middle |
| Apple | SO2 | 0.40 | 6.00 | Middle |
| Aspen | SO2 | 0.40 | 3.00 | Middle |
| Barley | SO2 | 1.30 | 1.00 | Very low |
| Bean | SO2 | 0.80 | 3.00 | Low |
| Begonia | SO2 | 0.30 | 1.00 | Very low |
| Broad bean | SO2 | 2.00 | 4.00 | High |
| Broccoli | SO2 | 0.30 | 4.00 | Low |
| Buckwheat | SO2 | 0.70 | 1.00 | Very low |
| Cabbage | SO2 | 1.00 | 4.00 | Low |
| Chrysanthemum | SO2 | 2.50 | 3.00 | Very high |
| Cocksfoot | SO2 | 3.10 | 6.00 | Very high |
| Cucumber | SO2 | 0.80 | 4.00 | Low |
| Dandelion | SO2 | 2.00 | 4.00 | High |
| Douglas fir | SO2 | 0.70 | 4.50 | Middle |
| French marigold | SO2 | 2.00 | 2.00 | High |
| Geranium | SO2 | 2.00 | 2.00 | High |
| Ginkgo | SO2 | 2.80 | 3.00 | Very high |
| Gladiolus | SO2 | 0.50 | 8.00 | Middle |
| Iris | SO2 | 0.50 | 8.00 | Middle |
| Italian ryegrass | SO2 | 1.90 | 6.00 | High |
| Larch | SO2 | 0.30 | 8.00 | Low |
| Lettuce | SO2 | 1.00 | 2.00 | Low |
| Locust tree | SO2 | 2.00 | 4.00 | High |
| Lucerne | SO2 | 0.10 | 4.00 | Low |
| Lilac | SO2 | 0.30 | 6.00 | Middle |
| Tomato | NH3 | 8.30 | 5.00 | Low |
| White clover | NH3 | 100.00 | 0.10 | Middle |
| African marigold | C2H4 | 0.01 | 20.00 | Low |
| Cattleya orchid | C2H4 | 0.00 | 24.00 | Very low |
| Aspen | O3 | 0.15 | 2.00 | Low |
| Bean | O3 | 0.06 | 8.00 | Low |
| Begonia | O3 | 0.13 | 3.00 | Low |
| Bindweed | O3 | 0.20 | 4.00 | Low |
| Apple | C2H4 | 0.01 | 48.00 | Middle |
| Buckwheat | C2H4 | 0.05 | 48.00 | Middle |
| Carnation | C2H4 | 0.10 | 6.00 | Low |
| Chrysanthemum | C2H4 | 1.00 | 9.00 | High |
| Cucumber | C2H4 | 100.00 | 6.00 | Very high |
| Fat hen | C2H4 | 0.05 | 48.00 | Middle |
| Forsythia | C2H4 | 0.70 | 20.00 | High |
| Narcissus | C2H4 | 0.40 | 1.00 | Very low |
| Pepper | C2H4 | 0.10 | 8.00 | Low |
| Rose | C2H4 | 10.00 | 24.00 | Very high |
| Snapdragon | C2H4 | 0.50 | 1.00 | Very low |
| Strawberry | C2H4 | 1.00 | 24.00 | High |
| Sunflower | C2H4 | 0.05 | 48.00 | Middle |
| Tomato | C2H4 | 1.00 | 24.00 | Middle |
| Tulip | C2H4 | 0.40 | 1.00 | Very low |
| Norway maple | SO2 | 2.50 | 3.00 | High |
| Oats | SO2 | 1.00 | 1.00 | Low |
| Onion | SO2 | 1.00 | 4.00 | Low |
| Pea | SO2 | 1.00 | 1.00 | Low |
| Petunia | SO2 | 2.00 | 4.00 | High |
| Pine | SO2 | 0.30 | 2.00 | Low |
| Plantain | SO2 | 0.80 | 6.00 | Middle |
| Poplar | SO2 | 2.00 | 4.00 | High |
| Potato | SO2 | 4.20 | 1.00 | Middle |
| Radish | SO2 | 0.50 | 1.00 | Low |
| Red fescue | SO2 | 1.20 | 6.00 | Middle |
| Rose | SO2 | 0.70 | 6.00 | Middle |
| Rye | SO2 | 0.70 | 3.00 | Low |
| Ryegrass | SO2 | 1.00 | 6.00 | Low |
| Fat hen | NH3 | 12.00 | 4.00 | Middle |
| Lettuce | NH3 | 2.00 | 24.00 | Low |
| Ryegrass | NH3 | 100.00 | 0.20 | Middle |
| Smooth-stalk meadow grass | NH3 | 12.00 | 4.00 | Middle |
| Silver birch | SO2 | 0.90 | 2.00 | Low |
| Smooth-stalk meadow grass | SO2 | 0.20 | 2.00 | Low |
| Snapdragon | SO2 | 4.00 | 2.00 | High |
| Spruce | SO2 | 3.00 | 6.00 | Very high |
| Spinach | SO2 | 1.00 | 4.00 | Low |
| Sweet pea | SO2 | 0.80 | 3.00 | Low |
| Swiss chard | SO2 | 1.00 | 1.00 | Low |
| Timothy | SO2 | 0.80 | 1.00 | Low |
| Tomato | SO2 | 0.50 | 4.00 | Low |
| Turnip | SO2 | 1.00 | 2.00 | Low |
| Wheat | SO2 | 0.80 | 1.00 | Low |
| Annual poa | HF | 0.10 | 4.00 | Low |
| Apple | HF | 0.40 | 4.50 | Middle |
| Azalea | HF | 0.10 | 48.00 | High |
| Bean | HF | 0.70 | 2.30 | Middle |
| Buckwheat | HF | 0.70 | 2.30 | Middle |
| Celery | HF | 0.10 | 48.00 | High |
| Chickweed | HF | 0.10 | 4.00 | Low |
| Corn | HF | 0.10 | 4.00 | Low |
| Dandelion | HF | 0.10 | 4.00 | Low |
| Dock | HF | 0.50 | 8.00 | High |
| Fat hen | HF | 0.10 | 4.00 | Low |
| Gladiolus | HF | 0.06 | 6.00 | Very low |
| Iris | HF | 0.50 | 8.00 | High |
| Lucerne | HF | 0.10 | 48.00 | High |
| Nettle-leaved goosefoot | HF | 0.10 | 4.00 | Low |
| Norway spruce | HF | 0.20 | 5.80 | Low |
| Pine | HF | 0.07 | 4.00 | Very low |
| Polygonum | HF | 0.50 | 8.00 | High |
| Rose | HF | 0.50 | 8.00 | High |
| Smoot-stalk meadow grass | HF | 0.10 | 4.00 | Low |
| Sunflower | HF | 0.10 | 4.00 | Low |
| Tomato | HF | 0.30 | 3.00 | Low |
| Tulip | HF | 0.50 | 8.00 | High |
| Azalea | Nox | 13.00 | 1.00 | Middle |
| Awnless brome | Nox | 4.00 | 0.50 | Very low |
| Bean | Nox | 6.00 | 2.00 | Low |
| Beet | Nox | 30.00 | 1.00 | High |
| Begonia | Nox | 16.00 | 0.50 | Middle |
| Broccoli | Nox | 16.00 | 0.50 | Middle |
| Buckwheat | Nox | 4.00 | 4.00 | Low |
| Chrysanthemum | Nox | 4.00 | 0.50 | Very low |
| Corn | Nox | 4.00 | 0.50 | Very low |
| Cocksfoot | Nox | 4.70 | 6.00 | Low |
| Cucumber | Nox | 6.00 | 2.00 | Low |
| Erica heather | Nox | 1000.00 | 1.00 | Very high |
| Sunflower | NH3 | 3.00 | 4.00 | Very low |
| Italian ryegrass | Nox | 4.70 | 6.00 | Low |
| Lettuce | Nox | 30.00 | 1.00 | High |
| Lucerne | Nox | 6.00 | 8.00 | Low |
| Oats | Nox | 4.00 | 0.50 | Very low |
| Pea | Nox | 6.00 | 4.00 | Low |
| Plantain | Nox | 3.30 | 6.00 | Low |
| Potato | Nox | 30.00 | 1.00 | High |
| Radish | Nox | 4.00 | 0.50 | Very low |
| Rape | Nox | 30.00 | 1.00 | High |
| Rye | Nox | 30.00 | 1.00 | High |
| Ryegrass | Nox | 4.70 | 6.00 | Low |
| Red fescue | Nox | 4.70 | 6.00 | Low |
| Smooth-stalk meadow grass | Nox | 4.70 | 6.00 | Low |
| Spinach | Nox | 6.00 | 2.00 | Low |
| Swiss chard | Nox | 1.00 | 1.00 | Very low |
| Timothy | Nox | 4.70 | 6.00 | Low |
| Tomato | Nox | 8.00 | 1.00 | Low |
| Wheat | Nox | 5.00 | 0.50 | Very low |
| Azalea | Cl2 | 0.80 | 4.00 | Low |
| Azalea | Cl2 | 0.80 | 4.00 | Middle |
| Bean | Cl2 | 1.30 | 0.50 | Low |
| Begonia | Cl2 | 1.00 | 4.00 | High |
| Buckwheat | Cl2 | 0.50 | 1.00 | Low |
| Carnation | Cl2 | 0.50 | 4.00 | Middle |
| Clover | Cl2 | 35.00 | 2.00 | Middle |
| Corn | Cl2 | 0.10 | 4.00 | Very low |
| Cucumber | Cl2 | 0.50 | 4.00 | Middle |
| Dahlia | Cl2 | 0.50 | 4.00 | Middle |
| Dandelion | Cl2 | 0.50 | 4.00 | Middle |
| Fat hen | Cl2 | 1.00 | 4.00 | High |
| Geranium | Cl2 | 0.80 | 4.00 | High |
| Lucerne | Cl2 | 0.10 | 2.00 | Very low |
| Maple | Cl2 | 0.10 | 4.00 | Very low |
| Nasturtium | Cl2 | 0.50 | 4.00 | Middle |
| Onion | Cl2 | 0.80 | 4.00 | High |
| Petunia | Cl2 | 0.10 | 4.00 | Very low |
| Pine | Cl2 | 1.00 | 3.00 | High |
| Polygonum | Cl2 | 1.00 | 4.00 | High |
| Radish | Cl2 | 0.10 | 2.00 | Very low |
| Rose | Cl2 | 1.00 | 0.50 | Low |
| Ryegrass | Cl2 | 35.00 | 0.20 | Middle |
| Squash | Cl2 | 0.80 | 4.00 | High |
| Sunflower | Cl2 | 0.10 | 2.00 | Very low |
| Tomato | Cl2 | 0.50 | 4.00 | Middle |
| Zinnia | Cl2 | 0.10 | 4.00 | Low |
| Buttercup | O3 | 0.20 | 4.00 | Low |
| Chrysanthemum | O3 | 0.26 | 3.00 | Low |
| Corn | O3 | 0.10 | 2.00 | Low |
| Corsican pine | O3 | 0.25 | 4.00 | Low |
| European larch | O3 | 0.25 | 4.00 | Low |
| Grape | O3 | 0.40 | 4.00 | Middle |
| Lettuce | O3 | 0.15 | 2.00 | Low |
| Lucerne | O3 | 0.15 | 4.00 | Low |
| Oats | O3 | 0.10 | 2.00 | Very low |
| Pea | O3 | 0.10 | 2.00 | Very low |
| Poplar | O3 | 0.18 | 4.00 | Low |
| Radish | O3 | 0.08 | 2.00 | Very low |
| Red clover | O3 | 0.15 | 4.00 | Low |
| Scots pine | O3 | 0.25 | 8.00 | Middle |
| Smooth-stalk meadow grass | O3 | 0.10 | 17.50 | Very high |
| Spinach | O3 | 0.13 | 3.00 | Low |
| Tobacco | O3 | 0.05 | 5.00 | Very low |
| Common vetch | O3 | 0.20 | 4.00 | Low |
| Weymouth pine | O3 | 0.07 | 4.00 | Very low |
| Wheat | O3 | 0.23 | 3.00 | Low |
| White clover | O3 | 0.15 | 4.00 | Low |
| Bean | PAN | 0.05 | 4.00 | Low |
| Petunia | PAN | 0.01 | 8.00 | Low |
| Tomato | PAN | 0.01 | 4.00 | Low |
| Lettuce | PAN | 0.05 | 12.00 | High |
| Small nettle | PAN | 0.05 | 35.00 | Very high |
| Annual poa | PAN | 0.05 | 42.00 | Very high |
| Phalaenopsis orchid | C2H4 | 0.00 | 24.00 | Very low |
AIR POLLUTANTS AND PLANT RESPONSES
| Cause | Common name | Botanical name | Plant part | Symptom |
| Acid mist pollution | Begonia | Begonia sp. | Leaf | Necrotic spots on upper surface at point of contact |
| Swiss chard | Beta vulgaris var. cicla | Leaf | Shot holing | |
| Boron pollution | Honeysuckle | Lonicera periclymenum | Leaf | Brown marginal necrosis; interveinal necrosis; cupping & distortion |
| Norway maple | Acer platanoides | Leaf | Brown marginal necrosis; interveinal necrosis;necrotic stipple; abscission | |
| Silver maple | Acer saccharinum | Leaf | Brown marginal necrosis, interveinal necrosis; cupping & distortion | |
| Spiraea | Spiraea sp. | Leaf | Abscission | |
| Br2 pollution | Bean | Phaseolus vulgaris | Leaf | Marginal necrosis |
| Beech | Fagus sylvatica | Leaf | Black spots, later whole leaf black/brown | |
| Corn | Zea mays | Leaf | Yellow tip, later necrotic | |
| Dahlia | Dahlia pinnata | Leaf | Brown discolouration; marginal necrosis | |
| Fir | Abies sp. | Needle | Red/brown discolouration, later grey/brown | |
| Larch | Larix decidua | Needle | Yellow/white tip | |
| Pea | Pisum sativum | Leaf | Marginal necrosis | |
| Pea | Pisum sativum | Tendril | Necrosis | |
| Rose | Rosa sp. | Leaf | Brown discolouration | |
| Rye | Secale cereale | Leaf | Yellow tip, later necrotic | |
| C2H4 pollution | Apple | Malus sylvestris | Flower | Intumescence formation |
| Apple | Malus sylvestris | Bark | Hypertrphy, especially around lenticels | |
| Azalea | Rhododendron sp. | Flower | Necrosis | |
| Beet | Beta vulgaris | Old leaf | Red/purple discolouration | |
| Carnation | Dianthus caryophyllus | Flower | Closing of flowers; ’sleepiness’ | |
| Cattleya orchid | Cattleya sp. | Sepal | Drying/bleaching from tip to base | |
| Cucumber | Cucumis sativus | Flower | Conversion of male into female | |
| Daffodil | Narcissus pseudonarcissus | Leaf | Inwards roll, curl or twist | |
| Hibiscus | Hibiscus sp. | Stem | Hypertrophy of lenticels | |
| Hyacinth | Hyacinthus sp. | Flower | Delayed opening; abnormal colour | |
| Hyacinth | Hyacinthus sp. | Leaf | Inwards roll, curl or twist; abscission | |
| Lettuce | Lectuca sativa | Young leaf | Dark green colouration | |
| Lilac | Syringa vulgaris | Bark | Hypertrphy, especially around lenticels | |
| Lily | Lilium sp. | Leaf | Inwards roll, curl or twist; abscission | |
| Marigold | Tagetus sp. | Stem | Root induction | |
| Pea | Pisum sativum | Young leaf | Dark green colouration | |
| Petunia | Petunia hybrida | Flower | Flowering inhibition | |
| Phalaenopsis orchid | Phalaenopsis sp. | Sepal | Drying/bleaching from tip to base | |
| Poplar | Populus sp. | Bark | Hypertrphy, especially around lenticels | |
| Radish | Raphanus sativus | Old leaf | Red/purple discolouration | |
| Radish | Raphanus sativus | Young leaf | Dark green colouration | |
| Rose | Rosa sp. | Flower | Premature opening | |
| Rose | Rosa sp. | Old leaf | Chlorosis, later necrosis | |
| Rose | Rosa sp. | Young leaf | Dark green colouration | |
| Snapdragon | Antirrhinum majas | Flower | Loss of petals | |
| Tomato | Lycopersicum esculentum | Stem | Root induction | |
| Tulip | Tulipa gesneriana | Leaf | Inwards roll, curl or twist; abscission | |
| Tulip | Tulipa gesneriana | New leaf | Continued folding | |
| Willow | Salix sp. | Bark | Hypertrphy, especially around lenticels | |
| Wych elm | Ulmus glabra | Bark | Loss of bark | |
| Cement pollution | Bean | Phaseolus vulgaris | Leaf | Margin rolling; interveinal necrosis; growth inhibition |
| Oats | Avena sativa | Leaf | Yellow spots | |
| Cl2 pollution | Apple | Malus sylvestris | Leaf | Abscission; marginal necrosis |
| Azalea | Rhododendron sp. | Leaf | Necrotic margins | |
| Barberry | Berberis vulgaris | Leaf | Marginal cholrosis | |
| Cherry | Prunus avium | Leaf | Necrotic stipple; abscission | |
| Chrysanthemum | Chrysanthemum sp. | Leaf | Necrotic stipple | |
| Dahlia | Dahlia pinnata | Leaf | Black marginal discolouration | |
| Dandelion | Taraxacum officinale | Leaf | Red discolouration | |
| Douglas fir | Pseudotsuga menziesii | Needle | Necrosis | |
| Fir | Abies sp. | Needle | Red/brown necrosis; narrow band of necrotic stipple between necrotic and healthy tissue | |
| Ginkgo | Ginkgo biloba | Leaf | Necrotic stipple | |
| Hibiscus | Hibiscus sp. | Leaf | Marginal cholrosis | |
| Horse chestnut | Aesculus hippocastanum | Leaf | White stipple | |
| Horse chestnut | Aesculus hippocastanum | Leaf | Marginal necrosis | |
| Larch | Larix decidua | Needle | Chlorotic mottle | |
| Lettuce | Lectuca sativa | Leaf | Necrotic margins; bronzing of lower surface | |
| Lucerne (alfalfa) | Medicago sativa | Leaf | Necrotic margins | |
| Oak | Quercus rubur (Q. pedunculata) | Leaf | Necrotic stipple; bronzing | |
| Onion | Allium cepa | Leaf | Tip necrosis | |
| Pear | Pyrus communis | Leaf | Black necrosis | |
| Peony | Paeonia sp. | Leaf | Necrotic margins | |
| Pine | Pinus sp. | Needle | Dull grey/green, later necrotic; orange necrosis; chlorotic mottle; narrow band of necrotic stipple between necrotic and healthy tissue | |
| Plum | Prunus domestica | Leaf | Necrotic stipple; marginal necrosis | |
| Rhododendron | Rhododendron | Leaf | Dark stipple, more on upper surface | |
| Rose | Rosa sp. | Leaf | Dark stipple, more on upper surface | |
| Spruce | Picea sp. | Needle | Red/brown necrosis; narrow band of necrotic stipple between necrotic and healthy tissue | |
| Squash | Cucurbita | Leaf | Cupping | |
| Sycamore | Acer pseudoplatanus | Leaf | Marginal necrosis | |
| Sycamore | Acer pseudoplatanus | Leaf | Black necrosis | |
| Tomato | Lycopersicum esculentum | Leaf | Cupping; epinasty | |
| Tulip | Tulipa gesneriana | Leaf | Bleached lower surface | |
| Wych elm | Ulmus glabra | Leaf | Marginal necrosis | |
| Yew | Taxus baccata | Needle | Black necorsis | |
| Fluoride pollution | Apple | Malus sylvestris | Leaf | Interveinal necrotic stipple; red/brown necrosis |
| Bilberry | Vaccinium sp. | Leaf | Red tip & margin discolouration | |
| Buckwheat | Fagopyrum esculentum | Leaf | Leaf cupping | |
| Cherry | Prunus avium | Fruit | Necrosis of stylar end | |
| Colorado spruce | Picea pungens | Young needle | Purple necrosis | |
| Corn | Zea mays | Leaf | Marginal chlorotic mottle; necrotic stipple, later necrotic streaks | |
| Cyclamen | Cyclamen | Sepals & petals | Marginal necrosis | |
| Dahlia | Dahlia pinnata | Leaf | Black necrosis | |
| Dandelion | Taraxacum officinale | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Gladiolus | Gladiolus sp. | Leaf | Glazed upper surface; red/brown necrosis | |
| Lilac | Syringa vulgaris | Leaf | Necrotic bands; red margin discolouration | |
| Lucerne (alfalfa) | Medicago sativa | Leaf | Marginal necrosis | |
| Oats | Avena sativa | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Peach | Prunus persica | Fruit | Premature ripening & suture rotting | |
| Pear | Pyrus communis | Fruit | Necrosis of stylar end | |
| Petunia | Petunia hybrida | Sepals & petals | Marginal necrosis | |
| Pine | Pinus sp. | Young needle | Reddish necrotic bands | |
| Poplar | Populus sp. | Leaf | Ivory necrosis; tip notching | |
| St. Johns Wort | Hypericum perforatum | Leaf | Red/brown necrosis | |
| Sunflower | Helianthus annuus | Leaf | Brown necrosis | |
| Tomato | Lycopersicum esculentum | Leaf | Edge curling; ivory necrosis | |
| Tulip | Tulipa gesneriana | Leaf | Glazed upper surface | |
| Wheat | Triticum vulgare | Leaf | Bleached tip; ivory necrosis | |
| H2S pollution | Aster | Callistephus chinensis | Flower | Necrosis of bracts |
| Buckwheat | Fagopyrum esculentum | Leaf | Upward rolling | |
| Sunflower | Helianthus annuus | Leaf | Distortion; orange interveinal necrosis | |
| HCl pollution | Aspen | Populus tremula | Leaf | Chlorotic mottle |
| Aster | Callistephus chinensis | Leaf | Bronzing/glazing of lower surface | |
| Bean | Phaseolus vulgaris | Leaf | Ivory necrosis; bronzing/glazing of lower surface; upward curling or rolling | |
| Beech | Fagus sylvatica | Leaf | Interveinal bleaching; necrotic stipple | |
| Cherry | Prunus avium | Leaf | Chlorotic mottle | |
| Cornflower | Centaurea cyanus | Leaf | Necrotic stipple; upward curling or rolling | |
| Cosmos | Cosmos bipinnatus | Sepal | Tip burn | |
| Cosmos | Cosmos bipinnatus | Leaf | Upward curling or rolling | |
| Cosmos | Cosmos bipinnatus | Petal | Discolouration | |
| Dahlia | Dahlia pinnata | Leaf | Black marginal discolourationg; black necrosis | |
| Maple | Acer sp. | Leaf | Necrotic stipple | |
| Marigold | Tagetus sp. | Sepal | Tip burn | |
| Nasturtium | Tropeolum majas | Leaf | Necrotic stipple; bleaching | |
| Oak | Quercus rubur (Q. pedunculata) | Leaf | Interveinal bleaching | |
| Pear | Pyrus communis | Leaf | Marginal necrosis | |
| Rose | Rosa sp. | Leaf | Black marginal discolourationg; marginal necrosis | |
| Silver birch | Betula pendula | Leaf | Marginal necrosis | |
| Tomato | Lycopersicum esculentum | Leaf | Bronzing/glazing of lower surface; bifacial bronzing, later necrotic | |
| Zinnia | Zinnia angustifolia | Leaf | Bronzing/glazing of lower surface; upward curling or rolling | |
| Zinnia | Zinnia angustifolia | Petal | Necrotic stipple | |
| Hg pollution | Privet | Ligustrum sp. | Leaf | Browning of interveinal tissue |
| Rose | Rosa sp. | Petal | Colour loss, later brown at margins | |
| Rose | Rosa sp. | Stamen/pistil | Black | |
| Rose | Rosa sp. | Bud | Remain closed, later necrosis | |
| Rose | Rosa sp. | Peduncle | Brown/black | |
| Rose | Rosa sp. | Flower | Abscission | |
| NH3 pollution | Apple | Malus sylvestris | Fruit | Purple/black/brown discolouration around lenticels |
| Azalea | Rhododendron sp. | Leaf | Brown/black necrosis | |
| Azalea | Rhododendron sp. | Flower | Brown & white marks on white and red flowers respectively | |
| Barley | Hordeum vulgare | Leaf | Bleaching | |
| Bean | Phaseolus vulgaris | Leaf | Red discolouration; red/brown/purple margins of necrotic areas | |
| Beech | Fagus sylvatica | Leaf | Bronzing/glazing of upper surface | |
| Broad bean | Vicia faba | Leaf | Yellow discolouration; later black | |
| Buttercup | Ranunculus sp. | Leaf | Yellow discolouration; later black | |
| Carrot | Daucus carota | Leaf | Brown/black necrosis | |
| Cauliflower | Brassica oleracea var. botrytis | Leaf | Ivory necrosis; black spots on lower surface | |
| Celery | Apium graveolens | Leaf | Red discolouration | |
| Clover | Trifolium sp. | Leaf | Red/brown/purple margins of necrotic areas | |
| Cocksfoot | Dactylis glomerata | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Cotoneaster | Cotoneaster sp. | Leaf | Yellow discolouration | |
| Dandelion | Taraxacum officinale | Leaf | Brown/black necrosis; red discolouration | |
| Forsythia | Forsythia intermedia | Leaf | Dark pigmented spots spreading & coalescing untill leaf becomes dark green/brown/black | |
| Gladiolus | Gladiolus sp. | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Hawthorn | Crataegus monogyna | Twig | Dieback | |
| Horse chestnut | Aesculus hippocastanum | Leaf | Dark pigmented spots spreading & coalescing untill leaf becomes dark green/brown/black | |
| Iris | Iris sp. | Leaf | Yellow discolouration | |
| Leek | Allium porrum | Leaf | Glazing; ivory necrosis | |
| Onion | Allium cepa | Leaf | Glazing; ivory necrosis | |
| Parsley | Petroselinum crispum | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Pea | Pisum sativum | Leaf | Purple/black/brown discolouration around lenticels | |
| Pear | Pyrus communis | Leaf | Dark pigmented spots spreading & coalescing untill leaf becomes dark green/brown/black | |
| Poplar | Populus sp. | Leaf | Bronzing/glazing of upper surface | |
| Potato | Solanum tuberosum | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Rhubarb | Rheum rhaponticum | Leaf | Red/brown/purple margins of necrotic areas; reddish necrosis | |
| Rye | Secale cereale | Leaf | Reddish necrosis | |
| Sorrel | Rumex acetosa | Leaf | Red/brown/purple margins of necrotic areas | |
| Sprouts | Brassica oleracea var. gemisera | Leaf | Black spots on lower surface | |
| Spruce | Picea sp. | Young needle | Red/yellow discolouration | |
| Spruce | Picea sp. | Needle | Pale green, becoming white and then red | |
| Stinging nettle | Urtica dioica | Leaf | Brown/black necrosis | |
| Strawberry | Fragaria vesca | Leaf | Red discolouration | |
| Sycamore | Acer pseudoplatanus | Leaf | Dark pigmented spots spreading & coalescing untill leaf becomes dark green/brown/black; yellow discolouration | |
| Wheat | Triticum vulgare | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Willow | Salix sp. | Leaf | Bronzing/glazing of upper surface | |
| Nox pollution | Alder | Alnus glutinosa | Leaf | Red/brown necrosis |
| Annual poa | Poa annua | Leaf | Glazing | |
| Apple | Malus sylvestris | Leaf | Red/brown necrosis | |
| Apple | Malus sylvestris | Leaf | Herringbone necrosis | |
| Aspen | Populus tremula | Leaf | Ivory necrosis, often with dark brown border | |
| Aster | Callistephus chinensis | Leaf | Orange/brown necrosis | |
| Azalea | Rhododendron sp. | Leaf | Orange/brown necrosis | |
| Barley | Hordeum vulgare | Awn | Tip necrosis | |
| Bean | Phaseolus vulgaris | Leaf | Marginal necrosis | |
| Beech | Fagus sylvatica | Leaf | Red/brown necrosis | |
| Beech | Fagus sylvatica | Leaf | Herringbone necrosis | |
| Begonia | Begonia sp. | Leaf | Shot holing with coloured margin | |
| Cabbage | Brassica oleracea var. capitata | Leaf | Necrotic stipple; bronzing/glazing | |
| Carnation | Dianthus caryophyllus | Leaf | Tip necrosis | |
| Carrot | Daucus carota | Leaf | Tip necrosis | |
| Clover | Trifolium sp. | Leaf | Marginal necrosis | |
| Cocksfoot | Dactylis glomerata | Leaf | Yellow/orange necrosis | |
| Dahlia | Dahlia pinnata | Leaf | Orange/brown necrosis | |
| Fir | Abies sp. | Old needle | Abscission after several months; sharp red/brown band between necrotic and healthy tissue | |
| Gooseberry | Ribes uva-crispa | Leaf | Tip necrosis | |
| Hazel | Corylus avellana | Leaf | Ivory necrosis, often with dark brown border; herringbone necrosis | |
| Kohlrabi | Brassica oleracea var. gongylodes | Leaf | Necrotic stipple | |
| Larch | Larix decidua | Old needle | Abscission after several months | |
| Lettuce | Lectuca sativa | Leaf | Necrotic stipple; ivory necrosis; shot holing with coloured margin | |
| Lucerne (alfalfa) | Medicago sativa | Leaf | Marginal necrosis | |
| Lupin | Lupinus angustifolium | Leaf | Marginal necrosis | |
| Maple | Acer sp. | Leaf | Red/brown necrosis | |
| Oak | Quercus rubur (Q. pedunculata) | Leaf | Red/brown necrosis; marginal necrosis; ivory necrosis, often with dark brown border | |
| Ox-eye daisy | Chrysanthemum leucanthemum | Leaf | Orange/brown necrosis | |
| Parsley | Petroselinum crispum | Leaf | Tip necrosis | |
| Pea | Pisum sativum | Leaf | Marginal necrosis | |
| Pear | Pyrus communis | Leaf | Black necrosis | |
| Pine | Pinus sp. | Old needle | Abscission after several months | |
| Pine | Pinus sp. | Old needle | Bleaching, later necrosis | |
| Pine | Pinus sp. | Old needle | Ring of white spots close to base | |
| Pine | Pinus sp. | Old needle | Sharp red/brown band between necrotic and healthy tissue | |
| Plantain | Plantago sp. | Leaf | Ivory necrosis; bronzing/glazing | |
| Potato | Solanum tuberosum | Leaf | Black marginal stipple | |
| Rhododendron | Rhododendron | Leaf | Necrotic stipple | |
| Rye | Secale cereale | Awn | Tip necrosis | |
| Silver birch | Betula pendula | Leaf | Ivory necrosis, often with dark brown border | |
| Spinach | Spinacea oleracea | Leaf | Bronzing/glazing; shot holing with coloured margin | |
| Spruce | Picea sp. | Old needle | Immediate abscission | |
| Sweet William | Dianthus barbatus | Bracts | Tip necrosis | |
| Sweet William | Dianthus barbatus | Sepals | Tip necrosis | |
| Timothy | Phleum pratense | Leaf | Basal necrosis | |
| Tulip | Tulipa gesneriana | Leaf | Basal necrosis | |
| O3 pollution | Apple | Malus sylvestris | Fruit | Tissue collapse around lenticels |
| Apple | Malus sylvestris | Leaf | Bronzing by very dense small lesions, mostly on upper surface | |
| Ash | Fraxinus excelsior | Leaf | Dense to sparse purple/reddish stipple of upper surface, bounded by smallest veins | |
| Barley | Hordeum vulgare | Leaf | Fine chlorotic/white/tan streaks between large veins, more at leaf bendings & seedling tips/margins | |
| Bean | Phaseolus vulgaris | Leaf | Brown necrotic lesions on upper surface, darker on first trifoliate leaf | |
| Bean | Phaseolus vulgaris | Fruit | Rows of necrotic lesions | |
| Citrus | Citrus sp. | Fruit | Premature drop | |
| Corn | Zea mays | Leaf | Light tan/white bifacial irregular necrotic streaks severe on margins occurring at tips in young leaf pregressively downwards on old leaf; bands of small silver grey/light tan necrotic steaks | |
| Grape | Vitis vinifera | Leaf | Dense to sparse purple/reddish stipple of upper surface, bounded by smallest veins | |
| Lilac | Syringa vulgaris | Leaf | Curling with drying of tip & margin | |
| Lime | Tilia cordia | Leaf | Bronzing by very dense small lesions, mostly on upper surface | |
| Lucerne (alfalfa) | Medicago sativa | Leaf | White/light yellow-green/silvergrey/tan variable necrosis on all or limited area | |
| Maple | Acer sp. | Leaf | Dense to sparse purple/reddish stipple of upper surface, bounded by smallest veins | |
| Oats | Avena sativa | Leaf | Fine chlorotic/white/tan streaks between large veins, more at leaf bendings & seedling tips/margins | |
| Onion | Allium cepa | Leaf | White fleck, later brown tips | |
| Pea | Pisum sativum | Leaf | Fawn lesions | |
| Pine | Pinus sp. | Needle | Chlorotic mottling, later tip burn | |
| Plane | Platanus sp. | Leaf | Dense to sparse purple/reddish stipple of upper surface, bounded by smallest veins | |
| Poplar | Populus sp. | Leaf | Dark brown bifacial necrotic lesions | |
| Silver birch | Betula pendula | Leaf | Bleaching of upper surface except at margins | |
| Snowberry | Symphoricarpos albus | Leaf | Bleaching of upper surface except at margins | |
| Spinach | Spinacea oleracea | Leaf | Dull white/tan lesions; large bifacial necrosis | |
| Tobacco | Nicotiana tobacum | Leaf | Numerous small white/tan bifacial lesions on upper surface, larger and more on more sensitive varieties | |
| Weymouth pine | Pinus strobus | Needle | Chlorotic flecks, later pink lesions and then orange-red tip necrosis | |
| Wheat | Triticum vulgare | Leaf | Fine chlorotic/white/tan streaks between large veins, more at leaf bendings & seedling tips/margins | |
| Salts pollution | Hawthorn | Crataegus monogyna | Branch | Tip-dieback |
| Maple | Acer sp. | Leaf | Yellow necrosis | |
| Poplar | Populus sp. | Leaf | Abscission | |
| Willow | Salix sp. | Leaf | Brown necrosis | |
| So2 pollution | Apple | Malus sylvestris | Leaf | Reddish necrosis; red discolouraion |
| Azalea | Rhododendron sp. | Leaf | Reddish necrosis | |
| Beech | Fagus sylvatica | Leaf | Brown/orange necrosis; red discolouraion; necrotic stipple | |
| Begonia | Begonia sp. | Leaf | Shot holing | |
| Blackberry | Rubus fruticosus | Leaf | Brown necrosis | |
| Bracken | Pteridium aquilinum | Frond | Orange/red marginal necrosis | |
| Broad bean | Vicia faba | Leaf | Black necrosis | |
| Cabbage | Brassica oleracea var. capitata | Leaf | Red discolouration around necrotic areas | |
| Carrot | Daucus carota | Leaf | Tip necrosis | |
| Cherry | Prunus avium | Leaf | Red discolouraion | |
| Chrysanthemum | Chrysanthemum sp. | Leaf | Brown necrosis | |
| Corn | Zea mays | Leaf | Red discolouration | |
| Daffodil | Narcissus pseudonarcissus | Leaf | Light brown necrosis; sharp band between necrotic and healthy tissue | |
| Dandelion | Taraxacum officinale | Leaf | Brown necrosis | |
| Fir | Abies sp. | Old needle | Immediate abscission | |
| Fir | Abies sp. | Middle age needle | Sharp boundry between necrotic and healthy tissue ater 3 wks of exposure | |
| Fir | Abies sp. | Young shoot | Twist | |
| Fuschia | Fuschia hybrida | Leaf | Distortion, puckering, curling | |
| Geranium | Pelargonium sp. | Leaf | Distortion, puckering, curling; grey necrosis | |
| Gladiolus | Gladiolus sp. | Sepal | Tip necrosis | |
| Gooseberry | Ribes uva-crispa | Leaf | Red stipple on upper surface; tip necrosis | |
| Hazel | Corylus avellana | Leaf | Brown/orange necrosis | |
| Hydrangea | Hydrangea macrophylla | Leaf | Red discolouration around necrotic areas | |
| Larch | Larix decidua | Middle age needle | Necrosis | |
| Lettuce | Lectuca sativa | Leaf | Dark spots on lower surface; shot holing | |
| Lily of the Valley | Convallaria majalis | Leaf | Sharp band between necrotic and healthy tissue | |
| Lime | Tilia cordia | Leaf | Brown/orange necrosis | |
| Lucerne (alfalfa) | Medicago sativa | Leaf | Bronzing of lower surface | |
| Lucerne (alfalfa) | Medicago sativa | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Maple | Acer sp. | Leaf | Distortion, puckering, curling | |
| Marigold | Tagetus sp. | Sepal | Tip necrosis before leaf injury | |
| Marigold | Tagetus sp. | Leaf | Large, bifacial necrotic spots on margin; distortion, puckering, curling | |
| Oak | Quercus rubur (Q. pedunculata) | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Oats | Avena sativa | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Parsley | Petroselinum crispum | Leaf | Tip necrosis | |
| Pea | Pisum sativum | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Pear | Pyrus communis | Leaf | Black necrosis | |
| Pine | Pinus sp. | Terminal bud | Necrosis | |
| Pine | Pinus sp. | Young needle | Chlorosis | |
| Pine | Pinus sp. | Middle age needle | Sharp boundry between necrotic and healthy tissue ater 3 wks of exposure | |
| Pine | Pinus sp. | Old needle | Abscission after several months | |
| Pine | Pinus sp. | Young shoot | Necrosis | |
| Poplar | Populus sp. | Leaf | Reddish necrosis | |
| Raspberry | Rubus idaeus | Leaf | Marginal necrosis | |
| Red currant | Ribes rubrum | Leaf | Red stipple on upper surface | |
| Rose | Rosa sp. | Leaf | Red stipple on upper surface | |
| Rowan | Sorbus aucuparia | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Silver birch | Betula pendula | Leaf | Distortion, puckering, curling | |
| Silver birch | Betula pendula | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Spinach | Spinacea oleracea | Leaf | Shot holing | |
| Spruce | Picea sp. | Middle age needle | Necrosis | |
| Strawberry | Fragaria vesca | Leaf | Red discolouration around necrotic areas; brown necrosis | |
| Sweet William | Dianthus barbatus | Leaf | Tip necrosis | |
| Tulip | Tulipa gesneriana | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Violet | Viola sp. | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Wheat | Triticum vulgare | Leaf | Red discolouration | |
| Willow | Salix sp. | Leaf | Ivory necrosis | |
| Zinnia | Zinnia angustifolia | Leaf | Ivory necrosis |
August 11, 2008
PLANTS AS AMELIORATORS (MITIGATORS) OF POLLUTION
Many types of higher and lower plants and microorganisms have the capability to tolerate and absorb large amounts of gaseous, liquid and solid pollutants from the environment and decompose them into harmless substances. This ability of such organisms can be usefully exploited in the control of environmental pollution.
Plants cover about one third of the land area as forests and grasslands and another one third as agricultural crops. Large surface area of ponds, lakes, rivers and sea coasts is also covered with aquatic flora. All this vegetation provides huge surface area that can be gainfully used to trap pollutants from the environment. In this large vegetational cover, those plant species that can absorb large quantities of pollutants and accumulate them in their tissues without damage (tolerant-accumulator species) provide natural storehouses or sinks of various pollutants without any cost. Such plants are very important resource materials in environmental pollution control strategies. Generally, woody plants absorb more pollutants than herbaceous plants. Actively growing tissue of wood absorbs larger amounts of pollutants than dormant tissues. Therefore, trees are comparatively more useful than herbaceous plants in pollution control.
Use of tolerant-accumulator plats in the control of air and soil pollution involves:
- Identification of pollutant(s) present in the area,
- Identification of tolerant-accumulator plant species suitable for the climate and the pollution problem of the area and then
- Plantation of identified plant species in the area on available bare lands, fallow lands, community lands, waste lands, along roads, railway lines, canal banks as well as green belts, shelter belts, wind breaks, city forests, parks etc.
Trees reduce the velocity of air passing through them thus facilitating the absorption of pollutants by the foliage. Establishment of tolerant-accumulator epiphytic mosses and lichens on the trees may also help in absorption of pollutants. Many microorganisms that can degrade pollutants to harmless substances are also established on the leaves as phyllosphere. Many plants absorb pollutants from the soil and thus check their runoff into water bodies or their leaching into the groundwater.
Use of plants in the control of water pollution mostly involves treatment of sewage an industrial effluents before their release into lakes or rivers and treatment of polluted water bodies. Introduction and maintenance of accumulator aquatic plants like Eichhornia, Azolla, Cladophora, Fontinalis squamosa etc. in the ponds is very effective in cleaning polluted water and keeping them free of organic, chemical and metal pollution. Most important sewage and effluent treatment systems using plants are:
Peat moss treatment systems: Many types of systems have been designed to treat urban sewage and industrial effluents using Sphagnum moss. These can treat upto 91,000 litres of effluent per day. Effluents are passed through columns containing the moss, which absorbs metals and the used up moss is then destroyed. Pre-treatment of moss with CaCO3 increases the metal absorption.
Eichhornia treatment systems: Diluted sewage or industrial effluent is passed through a zig-zag system of ponds and canals in which Eichhornia plants are grown. These plants asorb pollutants and retain them in their rhizomes. Plants from these hyacinth lagoons are regularly harvested and can be used to produce biogas in suitable digesters or after extraction of absorbed metals, can be used in making paper, boards etc. In the lagoons, the growth and death rates of plants are continuously monitored and managed by regulating the dissolved oxygen, biological oxygen demand and chemical oxygen demand, pH, turbidity and conductivity of the water at different stages of cleaning.
Microbial treatment/biogas systems: Treatment systems for organic sewage use suitable aerobic/anaerobic decomposer bacteria, ammnifying and sulphur bacteria in anaerobic lagoons. The organic matter in he polluted water is decomposed producing methane and carbon dioxide. In such systems, combination of decomposer bacteria and algae like Spirulina, Scendesmus, Clorella etc. can also be used. The decomposed organic matter is used up by algal growth. These protein-rich algal cultures can be regularly harvested and used as cattle feed. In the biogas systems, anaerobic bacterial decomposition of organic matter produces combustible gas. The freed metals and other pollutants are removed and clean effluent is used as rich fertilizer.
Many bacteria can absorb metals (e.g. Thiobacillus ferrooxidans and T. thiooxidans absorb copper), degrade petroleum oil (Pseudomonas sp.) or other chemicals. Genetic engineering is being applied to create new and more efficient strains of bacteria for use in mining and industries to control metal pollution, to clean oil spills, to degrade herbicides and pesticides in the soil and to absorb SO2 from chimney gases before their release into the atmosphere. Pseodomonas, Staphylococcus and a cornybacterium that accumulate metal bearing particles like silver, Aspergillus and Penicilium that concentrate uranium and phosphate are examples of such useful bacteria. Sulphur bacteria like Chlorobium, Chromatium and Thiospirillum may be helpful in control of SO2 pollution of air.
August 4, 2008
PLANTS AS INDICATORS AND MONITORS OF POLLUTION
Plants can effectively be used as cheap and naturally available monitoring systems or bioassays of the level and type of air, soil and water pollution in an area. The type and concentration of a pollutant can be reliably found out by various characteristics damage symptoms produced in the plants because such damage symptoms are pollutant specific as well as concentration specific. For example, in young needles of Pinus, chlorois indicates SO2 pollution, necrosis indicates HF pollution, beaching indicates NO2 pollution while chlorotic mottle indicates Cl2 pollution in the atmosphere. These characteristic symptoms of damage in young pine needles appear only when concentration is 0.3 ppm for SO2, 0.07 ppm for HF and 1.0 ppm for Cl2. Similarly, browning in moss leaves due to fluoride accumulation is 5% in 65 ppm dry weight accumulation but rises to 90% in 4500 ppm dry weight accumulation. However, certain precautions have to be taken while using plants as pollution indicators.
Precautions in use of plants as pollution indicators
-
The damage symptoms in plants should preferably be studied in the local native species. Cultivated and introduced species should be avoided.
-
The species sensitive to pollutants should be first identified in the local flora and then used for pollution monitoring. Tolerant species should be identified and avoided in such work.
-
Damage symptoms for a particular pollutant should be studied in different species sensitive to that pollutant so that presence of the pollutant in the area may be cross-checked. For example, grey necrosis in Geranium, ivory necrosis in Zinnia, brown necrosis in Chrysanthemum and reddish necrosis in Azalea indicates absolutely certain presence of SO2 pollution in the area.
-
Many types of damage symptoms viz. morphological, anatomical, ultra-structural physiological, biochemical etc. should be studied in one or more sensitive plant species to ascertain the presence of a particular pollutant in the area.
-
Samples should be taken from as many different sites in the area as possible. From such data the extent of pollution can be determined and the possibility of symptoms being due to some pathogen is also excluded because the intensity of damage symptoms due to pollution varies in different sites according to the distance from the source of pollution while it is same in all sites in case of a pathogenic disease.
-
The possibility of damage symptoms in plants occurring due to some cause other than pollution e.g. due to pathogen, environmental condition or nutritional deficiency/excess should be thoroughly checked and ruled out.
Important characteristics of plant species used in pollution monitoring
The plant species used to monitor pollution in an area should have certain important features for the success of such programme. Most important such features are:
-
Species should be easy to identify in the field and easy to handle for damage analysis.
-
Species should have a wide range of distribution so that it can be used in different areas.
-
Species should be sensitive to many types of pollutants so that it can be used to monitor different types of pollutants in the area.
-
Species should produce highly specific damage symptoms in response to particular types and concentrations of pollutants.
Plants commonly used as pollution indicators
Though all types of sensitive species can be used in monitoring pollution, most useful and commonly used plants include sensitive species of lichens, mosses, plankton algae, aquatic ferns and angiosperms, other ferns, conifers oaks and many crop plants. Mosses, lichens, ferns algae and aquatic plants are generally more useful in pollution monitoring because their range of pollutant specificity is usually much higher than that of higher vascular plants. Examples of some common types of plants useful as pollution monitors are given below.
Plant type |
Plants |
|
AIR & SOIL POLLUTION
|